The World in 2029
I'm on a mission to explore what the world might look like in 2029. The podcast features interviews with tech startup founders and researchers, addressing pressing issues like climate change, hunger, and disease. These changemakers are aiming for a better world in 2029. The future is better than you think!
The World in 2029
The 3D-printed Flakey Salmon
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Can 3D-Printed Food Help Transform the Protein System?
What would it take to make alternative proteins appealing beyond vegans and vegetarians? In this episode, Lars Rinnan talks with David Petuzzi, CEO of Revo Foods, about using mycoprotein and industrial 3D food printing to create new protein products, including salmon-style fillets.
David explains how the company combines protein and fat to build texture, and how its printing technology moved from the lab through pilot production toward industrial scale. The conversation also looks at the challenges of changing how people eat: new foods need to be tasty, nutritious, convenient and affordable—not just offer a sustainability benefit.
Together, Lars and David explore the environmental and animal-welfare concerns surrounding conventional food production, why earlier alternative-meat products didn’t always win repeat customers, and how food companies can earn consumers’ trust. They also discuss startup funding, manufacturing costs, regulation and the future of food as Lars and David look ahead to 2029.
In this episode:
- Why David believes the food system needs a protein transition
- The resource-use and animal-welfare challenges of conventional meat and fish production
- Why food habits are so closely tied to culture, identity and emotion
- What went wrong when some early plant-based alternatives promised too much
- How 3D food printing layers protein and fat to create a salmon-like texture
- How Revo Foods developed continuous production and scaled beyond the lab
- Why flexible printing technology can create different shapes and products
- The challenge of increasing output while improving efficiency and controlling costs
- How a food-tech startup balances product development, investment and business fundamentals
- Why taste, nutrition, convenience and price matter for reaching flexitarian consumers
- How David responds to concerns about processed foods and changing food regulations
- What mycoprotein, precision fermentation and cell-based products could mean for future food choices
- How alternative proteins might contribute to a more efficient food system
Timestamps
00:45 Introducing The World in 2029 and Revo Foods
03:12 Why change how we produce protein?
05:38 Animal welfare and food production
07:05 Why changing food habits is difficult
08:19 Farmed fish and the case for new protein sources
11:47 Lessons from the first wave of alternative meats
13:25 How 3D food printing works
15:10 Building salmon-like texture with layers
18:17 Mycoprotein, ingredients and Revo Foods’ technology
21:06 What food printing can make possible
26:07 Moving from lab prototype to industrial production
28:52 Increasing output and improving efficiency
29:37 Funding and building a lean food-tech company
33:03 Price and the economics of alternative proteins
36:08 Winning over consumers
38:37 Reaching flexitarians
43:55 Processed-food concerns and the science
46:21 Regulation and how alternative products are named
48:10 New protein sources and what comes next
49:45 What might change in supermarket food by 2029?
52:20 How much of the protein challenge can new technologies solve?
54:10 Food production, efficiency and hunger
About the podcast
The World in 2029 explores how today’s innovations are shaping our future. Host Lars Rinnan looks at how pressing issues like climate change, hunger and disease are being addressed by exponential technologies that most people don’t know about.
If you enjoyed the conversation, subscribe, share the episode and leave a review.
David (00:00)
this is why we are convinced that there needs to be a different approach
just using animals in that way.
Lars (00:09)
Yeah, yeah. No, I fundamentally agree. This is probably going to piss off a large part of the aquaculture industry in Norway, but I I think it needs to be said. Absolutely.
maybe that gets kids to eat more salmon if it's star shaped or if it's shaped like their their favorite, cartoon figure or something like that.
David (00:28)
Yeah, exactly.
Lars (00:28)
you've chosen some gigantic adversaries. but sometimes sometimes
David (00:31)
Yeah.
Lars (00:33)
David beats Goliath. So you can be you can be David.
David (00:36)
Exactly.
Lars (00:45)
So, welcome to the World in 2029, the podcast where we explore how today's innovations are shaping our future. I'm your host, Lars, and I'm on a mission to spread positive insights into how today's pressing issues like climate change, hunger, and disease are being addressed by exponential technologies that most people don't know about.
I worked in the AI space for about 10 years and I've helped numerous tech startups. So this is a topic I know well and is extremely close to my heart. So today we're looking at a technology that could fundamentally change how humanity produces one of its most basic necessities, namely food. And my guest is David Petuzzi, CEO of Revo Foods.
An Austrian food tech company using mycoprotein and additive manufacturing to create new types of protein products. And unlike many futuristic food concepts, these products can already be produced industrially and sold to consumers.
David, welcome to the show. It's great to have you.
David (03:05)
Hi Lars, nice to be here, nice to be on the show. Thanks for your introduction as well. looking forward to the session.
Lars (03:12)
Perfect. let's jump straight into it and let's start with the problem, rather than the technology. Why do we actually need a protein transition? What is fundamentally wrong with the way we produce meat and fish today?
David (03:28)
if we look at how we eat and produce food today, it's inherently inefficient. we basically feed our animals with tons of food, like from soy to other sources. And the calories we get out of this system, so basically by feeding the animals, is inherently inefficient, which means that the resources
we feed the animals with and the calories we get out in the end from eating the animals is not efficient. And on top of this, we obviously have all the problems like looking at animal welfare from a moral and ethical point of Also, if you look at data globally, like a third of our global emissions are coming from the food system. So then we also have like a huge lever to have a positive impact
crisis to prevent it or change it to certain degree and have a positive impact for our future.
Lars (04:26)
That's a that's a huge chunk of the climate emissions, so one third. That's
David (04:31)
Mm-hmm.
Lars (04:32)
pretty that's pretty big. So but if if we look at, land, water, feed, emissions, biodiversity, or or even animal welfare, you know, where where are the biggest inefficiencies in in today's system?
David (04:48)
to point out one, I would say it's very difficult. In the end, that's also the climate crisis, the polly crisis, which means we have problems on many ends. problem or big part of this problem is how we consume food eating more plant-based will have a positive impact on all those different ends.
land usage, we'll significantly reduce how much land we need if we eat more plant-based. Same for water usage. Biodiversity will thrive again if we have less monocultures for soil production of, for example, who is then mainly fed to animals nowadays.
Lars (05:29)
Yeah. And I also guess that animal welfare, which is, is a it's a huge thing for a lot of I I guess that is also a big issue.
David (05:38)
we all know in the end the videos of how industrial animal farming looks it's just a cruelty what we do to animals here. and foremost, this is one of the reasons why we are doing what we're doing to treat animals better and also
give them a life that they deserve in the end without cruelty so that they can grow up in a natural way and not just to be a resource for humans that the only goal of raising an animal that it is killed in the end to be fed to humans.
Lars (06:15)
Yeah. Yeah, exactly.
Yeah. So was this a big driver for you as well, joining the company?
David (06:26)
I in a way there are many aspects to it, if I would have to choose one, this is definitely the biggest aspect of In a way the moral ambition to change how we treat animals.
if you look at videos and how they are treated, this is something that we want to avoid in the future and we obviously want to change. our idea behind this is, okay, we offer something where humans can change their diet without limiting themselves on like the pleasure and the culture and the identity.
you identify yourself with food. So this is our aim
Lars (07:05)
Yeah, well that's a that's a really good point. So but of course food is is a lot different from you know like energy or technology because it's it's so deeply connected to our culture. Like you say, it's it's a bit like identity and also emotion. Does that make changing the food system inherently harder than changing like the energy system?
David (07:28)
I would say so I actually talked to somebody the other day who worked in the energy transition for decades. And now we actually moved to trying to change the food system. he said basically while working on the energy transition, he he thought that's the biggest challenge he'll ever have in his life. And now working in changing the food system, he actually sees it differently.
Lars (07:52)
Yeah.
David (07:53)
Because in the end, it's very individually.
So when you connect to food is like I said a lot about emotion identity also habits also how you grew up very much defines what you're going to eat in the future changing this is very tough in the end you need to offer good solutions so that it's easier for people to change these habits that they have inherited for probably your life till now.
Lars (08:19)
Yeah, I think that's a huge part of it. of course, I I'm Norwegian and in Norway is one of the world's largest producers or producers of farmed salmon. I mean, we have, you know, these farms all around, you know, all across the the the coast of Norway And of course, aquaculture it made some really huge fortunes. It's also solved some problems, but
again it's created others. So is is is better fish farming enough? Or do we ultimately need to fundamentally you know produce different ways of of protein?
David (08:59)
If you look at how fish farming is done today, there are obviously a lot of problems because there are just too many fish on a too small space, which means they need to feed them with a lot of antibiotics so that the fish do not get sick and contagious. I think we all aware of these problems. What I see here for the future is, it possible for fish farming to be economically viable
by giving the fish more space, more water and so forth. This is something that the fish farmers have not solved yet and this consequently leads to all the problems that fish farming now has. Not even looking at also the moral aspect of fish farming for the fish that are swimming in the small farming waters.
Lars (09:47)
Yeah.
so so you you have no trust in that you know the fish farming industry is going to let's say improve itself enough that it will be your both sustainable and morally justifiable.
David (10:02)
In the end what consumers like the choice the consumers in the shop is that they want to buy something that tastes well, that is nutritious for themselves, but in the end also that is the cheapest most of the time so that the price is okay for them. If we look at fish farming, more fish they farm, the more economically reasonable it will be and the better the price will be.
So in the end, the farms with the most amount of fish will be able to have the lowest price. So they will basically push out the ones that...
try to farm more sustainable. And this leads to all the problems we now have already. So there's a reason that this grew like that. I guess like most fish farmers who started probably 50s, 60s, 70s, they didn't think that they would become so big and then by becoming so big treat the fish bad. But it's just like how this organically grew over time because there was the necessity from the market that they do it like this.
And now we see, okay, the results of this is that the quality goes down. the fish have mercury, they have antibiotics, have less healthy fatty acids like omega-3 and more unhealthy fats like saturated fats. This we see now in results and analysis they're taken from fish farming. this is why we are convinced that there needs to be a different approach
just using animals in that way.
Lars (11:34)
Yeah, yeah. No, I fundamentally agree. This is probably going to piss off a large part of the aquaculture industry in Norway, but I I think it needs to be said. Absolutely.
David (11:45)
agree as well.
Lars (11:48)
there's also been you know huge amounts of enthusiasm around alternative meats, but then also you know considerable backlash.
generation of of plant based products promise too much? what what did the industry get wrong, do you think?
David (12:05)
I totally agree that we promised too much and our expectations were also very different. If we look at the first Beyond Meat products, but then also all the other products that came out somewhere between 2018, 2021, 2022, we see that actually we thought, just replacing meat and fish with a plant-based alternative and offering those positive climates.
Aspects is enough for the consumer that they will switch to a plant-based diet This was maybe enough for them to try it but if you were not satisfied with the solution you have been offered Especially from a quality perspective, but also from a price point of view You will not eat it again or at least not on a repeating like repetitively every week for example, so
This in the end left a lot of consumers unsatisfied and this is now the challenge that we need to accept and also where we need to offer better solutions that basically satisfy the consumer demand on all ends on price quality nutrition, and also convenience. how the industry basically has developed over the past five to 10 years from just trying to
offer plant-based for its own sake to really offering a good product that the consumers are happy with.
Lars (13:25)
I totally agree. So well let's let's jump to how you actually do this. I mean, you know, one question is, you know, can you really print food? And if if you don't know about you know 3D printing or additive manufacturing, this this sounds like you know like a science fiction or like a technology demonstration, not something that's capable of feeding, you know, millions of people. let's let's try to
mystify what Revo actually does. well, the phrase that you often use in Chat GPT, explain explain this to me as as I'm 12 years old. So let's do that with with what you're producing. you know what what arrives at your factory, what what happens inside the machine and what you know what eventually comes out. So explain it like I'm 12.
David (14:13)
Yeah, first of all probably to add here and 3D printing is a very established manufacturing processes process in other industries like plastic yeah, you can basically print a lot of metal and plastic parts nowadays already with 3D printing. However, in a continuous process, so in a really a production process on an industrial scale, this was not
Lars (14:36)
Mm.
David (14:37)
the case for 3D food printing.
until we started it. And we came up with this idea because we wanted, our first product was actually a salmon fillet. And that's also why I think it's quite good to talk to someone from Norway with your heritage in fish farming.
Lars (14:57)
Yeah, we eat a lot of
salad.
David (15:00)
And it's a fantastic product it's also healthy if you eat the right one. And that's why we wanted to...
offer a good solution for the most eaten fish globally, salmon. And then we thought, okay, what does salmon actually make unique? why do people love it so much? a lot of it comes down to the texture of salmon. So if you look at it, it has this like nice texture. can take the layers apart. It's soft, but then still sticks together. falls apart, the flakes in your mouth.
then we thought a lot about, how can we actually imitate this fantastic texture
that Salman has? And then the idea came to 3D footprinting. Because what 3D footprinting offers is that we can, in our case, and in general, combine many materials together. And then we had the idea, okay, if we produce a
material that consists of the protein and then another material that is the fat then we integrate these into each other. We can create this layering and flakiness effect that Salman has. And this is actually what we do now. So our 3D footprinting machine has two material tanks. In one tank you have the protein material which mainly consists of the mycoprotein that we use. Maybe we'll come to this later.
And the other material tank has the fat material, is mainly oil and algae oil for the omega-3, for example, also a little bit of protein to give it the texture. And then we basically do a layering and produce extrude. So which means like creating a material flow from the material tank to the nozzles where the material comes out and put a layer on layer from
protein, fat, protein, fat. through this, you then bake it and the fat, for example, melts earlier than the protein mass, you create this nice texture that conventional salmon also has. And this is the goal and was the goal and is still the goal of our salmon filet. And that's how basically the idea started with 3D footprinting.
Lars (17:13)
fantastic. Of course this is why it's called additive manufacturing. you're you're building layer upon layer, so you're adding. and and how
David (17:20)
Exactly.
Lars (17:25)
what what makes it taste like salmon? Is there some kind of additive or flavor added to this?
David (17:33)
Exactly. So how our team works, we have the combination of hardware and software engineers who develop the machinery, but then they work very closely with our food scientists who develop the recipe. And then it's basically a back and forth between those two departments because a step forward in the recipe might be a step back in the additive manufacturing process or in the printing process. So there's a lot of back and forth
How we get actually to a good taste is by using a good protein source, is in our case the microprotein, then adding oil and flavors to the mouth so that you create a nice umami and salmony mouthfeel and taste.
Lars (18:17)
fantastic. all this is organic, I guess. Also the the taste components.
David (18:23)
Our ingredients are not grown organically, this is also quite an interesting point mycoprotein which is a fermented mushroom protein in the end will not be or can right now not be organic because it's fermented and grows industrially in the bioreactor and this is why our products are then not organic. So this is just like a side note on this.
Lars (18:48)
Yeah. And and this
microprotein, this is you don't produce the microprotein yourself. You you buy the raw material and then combine it with your own recipes like fats and oils and flavours, like you said. So so where does Reva's real technological IP
David (19:07)
In the end, we have an end-to-end process which begins by buying the ingredients. So then we have the raw materials and that's where our process So from the raw material to actually the end consumer. So we even deliver direct to consumer over online shop or that we place it in the retail stores on the shelf.
Our core IP in the end lays in the machinery. So we currently have three patterns. Two of them are
about the continuous process that we established with the 3D printing because until we started, 3D food printing was always a batch process. So you always had to refill the material. And we were the first ones who actually created a continuous material flow from the material tanks to the nozzles. So that's where two of our patents are coming from. And the third one is about the multi-nozzle system that we have.
on the machinery, because if we want to produce industrially, it's not enough to only have two nozzles per machinery. So right now we have 16 on there, which means that we exactly and for
Lars (20:12)
Sixteen.
David (20:14)
each unit, you need two nozzles. So one for the protein, one for the fat mass, and which means that we can produce eight filets at a time per machinery. So that's our current process
Lars (20:26)
Yeah, well very cool. And this is a like you said, this is patented. So you're the only ones globally that is actually producing fish filet, salmon filet like this.
David (20:40)
There's actually one competitor in the US who is doing it. They have also established their own process.
Lars (20:46)
Mm.
David (20:48)
however, like looking at all the fish that is eaten and also all the meat that is eaten globally, if there are just two who are doing this, I think there's enough demand for the
Lars (20:59)
Yeah.
David (21:01)
supply that we can offer.
Lars (21:02)
Yeah, absolutely. I think there's space for more than two companies really.
that's that's really cool. t what can a food printer achieve that, you know, traditional extrusion or moulding or you know other food processing technologies cannot.
David (21:19)
First of all, this integration of two or even more materials with each other creates opportunities that other processes do not have. With molding, you can mix material, but you cannot exactly define where each fat fiber or protein fiber sits in the end. additionally, you're super flexible in the form and structure that you're producing.
So in the end for us, we're just changing the software code and we can tell the machinery, okay, today you take a different path than yesterday. And instead of a salmon filet, you produce a chicken shape, for example, or a star shape, even if you think about it crazily. then if you want to do a different product like a chicken, you instead of a salmon recipe, use a chicken recipe and we have a different.
half or extrusion that the 3D printer does and then we can also produce a different product the next day. So this machinery and 3D footprinting is then very flexible to the output you want to generate and the products you want to produce.
Lars (22:25)
Yeah. Which is really cool. you you talked about star shaped, star shaped salmon. maybe that gets kids to eat more salmon if it's star shaped or if it's shaped like their their favorite, cartoon figure or something like that.
David (22:38)
Yeah, exactly. We talked about this that this would be like, yeah, super cool idea to bring out products that are specifically targeted to children, then healthy plant based products and not like the food industry is doing it now that they target children with mainly sugar or high in sugar
trying to change their behavior from early on so that they do not have these problems later on like we do now.
to change all our habits while we are an adult already. So that they grow up with a different food culture already where they think more about animal welfare and yeah, or just eat it without even thinking about it. To eat more plant-based without even thinking about all the complications that the food system has. Yeah, probably better put it that way.
Lars (23:22)
Yeah. you you actually
you actually called this software defined food. And you know I I really like that because that means that it's it's so flexible. You can make you know
David (23:34)
Uh
Lars (23:34)
make it in whatever shape or geometry or you can even change recipes. I mean you have the machines, you have the patent
David (23:41)
Mm-hmm.
Lars (23:42)
with the sixteen nozzles, so you can actually make just about whatever you like.
in terms of you know shapes and ingredients and I think that's really cool. Maybe that's even even more interesting than trying to let's say mimic nature and make you know salmon or or chicken or or octopus and and you could you can make you know something totally different. I think that's really cool.
David (24:10)
yeah, I agree. And this is also what we aim for. at the bidding, our big goal was to produce and develop a salmon filet. And once we achieved this, we were like, okay, what is our next step now? And then we said, okay, we need further need to develop ourselves as a company and also our technology to have a variety of products. And by now we can offer a chicken alternative.
whitefish fillet, but then also natural protein fillets, like you said, which do not mimic or replicate anything that is out there. this creates another problem, which is the consumer in the
Lars (24:49)
Yeah, yeah.
David (24:52)
This also kind of leads back to all the habits and behavior that we have and grew over time.
see a completely new product which doesn't replicate anything, you might at the beginning do not know what to do with it. So you think, okay, what do I combine it with? How do I bake it? Do I grill it? Do I need to season it? What do I do with it? And for this, need
Lars (25:12)
Yeah.
David (25:13)
a lot of education. And for a company, education means a lot of marketing and marketing spend and resources.
So for us, this was actually quite difficult to bring a product on the market, which doesn't replicate anything. We've tried this and we still didn't achieve what we wanted to because we think the product is fantastic,
The market doesn't accept it like the other products that actually mimic something that you do know already.
Lars (25:44)
Yeah, exactly. let's let's into the consumer part shortly. But before we do that, yeah, let's let's jump into let's say the the the factory part of this. I mean taking this from like a science experiment to to factory. Because we we all know that, you know, there there's food tech history, you know, it's it's full of fantastic technologies that you know worked
Brilliantly in the laboratory and failed spectacularly when somebody tried to
David (26:12)
Mm-hmm.
Lars (26:13)
manufacture them, economically. and I know that you've spent about five years developing the technology. at at what point did you realize that this is not just a prototype This is this can actually become an industrial production
David (26:33)
That's a very good point actually, because there was also the question, okay, when is it ready to make the step out of the lab and into producing industrially? And we questioned ourselves, we had this question a lot to ourselves as well. we decided then to basically do a bit of a step-by-step process where we go from lab to a really small pilot scale.
with very low output, but then we already saw, okay, this works for this next step. And once you have achieved this in that next step, you had a lot of learnings then you can further develop your technology. And then you take this even bigger step like pilot scale two. right now, after this pilot scale two step, we saw, okay, this is also working now. And then we had the next learnings and then you take it step by step.
over time, gained so much know-how that by now we can produce industrially. But this means, took us probably two years to get out of the lab into pilot scale. Then another year for pilot scale two, and then another year to actually really have an industrial output. that's where we are now. for now it's like, okay, further improving, making it even more efficient, increasing the scale.
So that's where we are at the moment.
Lars (27:51)
Yeah, Scaling is harder. What what was the hardest scaling problem for you guys? Was it like printing speed? Or was it machine reliability? Is it waste? is it cost? Where's the hardest scaling?
David (28:06)
think it's a combination of each one of them and always at different times you have different problems.
Lars (28:11)
Mm.
David (28:13)
At the beginning it was definitely to get to an output, so this was like the first problem. Once you have solved, okay now we have like a good output, you want to make it more efficient which means to produce faster and having lower based at the same time. And then once you correct this,
you're looking at the next step, okay, how can I improve it now? And then you look, okay, how can I twist it? So you have less manual intervention and the machinery can fully work independently. each step has its own challenges, but that also makes it very interesting.
Lars (28:46)
Yeah, so you you're always chasing the next bottleneck. Yeah, yeah.
David (28:50)
Exactly.
Lars (28:52)
So w what does the next order of magnitude improvement look like? What what's that going to be?
David (28:59)
right now we just brought out a new prototype there we had really significant improvements on the kinematics side which means that we can produce faster and more reliably. So with this new prototype for example we can, depending on the product, increase our daily output from 60 to 180 percent which means we can actually reach outputs of 100,000 units a month now
With this new machine design, we are also able to move or have this next step as a company where we can become profitable, which is our goal for the coming year.
Lars (29:37)
Absolutely, that's the that's the ultimate goal. capital and money, I mean you you told me this when we spoke earlier you know raising raising huge amounts of capital can sometimes hurt the startup. we we've seen this, you know, in in like in insect protein and other alternative protein businesses. what what what have you guys done differently?
David (30:01)
In the end, try to improve over time and show the progress and there will also be interest of investors.
Lars (30:08)
Mm.
David (30:09)
however, it's also difficult. I'm not saying that we have an easy time here, especially now with economic issues, especially in Western and middle Europe. We are located in Vienna
Yeah, economically the European Union is not doing super well and most of the investment money is now flowing into AI and the defense industry, which means that the protein or alternative protein industry and also the food system is left a bit behind because investment money just flows somewhere else. we are trying to be very lean as an organization.
And also by taking the step-by-step process, we were also able to reduce capex significantly compared to peers in our industry. by this, we were probably also more attractive to investors
Lars (31:01)
Mm, yeah. Yeah, but I also think that, having having too much money too early, you know, too much funding can actually
David (31:07)
Hmm.
Lars (31:08)
hurt the business because then you you kinda lose sight of of being lean and smart and know, we we don't have money to do the you know the the obvious thing, so we need to be smarter.
David (31:20)
Mm-hmm.
Lars (31:21)
I I think it's a good point.
And of course, you yourself, you you moved from the role of CFO in the company to become the CEO. And I I'm guessing that that in some way reflects the the the wider transition inside of Revo, from you know, from pro proving the technology to proving the economics. Is is that right?
David (31:45)
Yeah, in the end last year we had discussions and the idea of the CEO back then was to shift a bit around the team and basically make us ready for this next step that we now took in this year. through this, there was this transition from me as CFO to CEO and the back then founder and also chief executive officer took over the role as a commercial director.
to fully work on the sales and business development side.
Lars (32:14)
Yeah. And of course the the the the the CFO side will at some point be very important in the in the startups, you know
David (32:24)
It's maybe,
yeah, it's definitely something that is underestimated because you start with a science project, but the science also needs to make sense from a business point of view. Otherwise it will not work. And this is also something that a lot of startups do not think about at the beginning. And this is also a good tip for many startups out there to take someone with business knowledge.
into your team early on.
Lars (32:51)
Yeah, a hundred percent. Yeah, I totally agree. a lot a lot of companies miss that. they they're just looking at
David (32:56)
you
Lars (32:57)
the the fantastic technology, but someone has to sell it and it needs to be affordable. And talking about
David (33:02)
Exactly,
Lars (33:03)
affordable, this is perhaps a crucial question. Can can this actually become cheaper than conventional meat or fish? Or is it primarily more sustainable and ethical?
David (33:18)
Looking at the shelf right now, we actually on price parity with premium salmons. if you look at the prices, for example, for salmons, are somewhere between 20 and 60 euros per kilogram in the shelf in Austria and Germany. And we currently sell for 30 to 35 euros per kilo, means we are actually on price parity with not the cheapest salmon. This
little bit like a premium salmon and already cheaper than really organic wild caught fish for example.
Lars (33:48)
Yeah, exactly. and
you you're also probably having, conventional farming, you know, land or sea based is is you know is very linear. but you're actually using an exponential technology. So this
Let's say traditional aqua farming. Isn't that right?
David (34:09)
Yeah, if we look at it right now, a lot also comes down to the regulation or regulatory framework and also subsidy framework that has been installed over the past decades since World War II.
Lars (34:23)
Oh.
David (34:24)
the idea here was to subsidize the meat and fish industry very heavily to have as much supply as possible to nurture all of us, which also
made sense back then after World War II to not have the issues of hunger and that everyone, at least in our sphere, is fed. But this created a lot of issues that we discussed previously already with animal welfare and so on. see, okay, now we need to make this next step and transform the food system
have established it over the past 80 years. part of this transformation is going from animal proteins to plant-based proteins.
Because in the end, there's no way if there would be, if the regulations would be on par for both industries, that the plant-based industry would be cheaper. Because it's just more efficient. We don't have to feed animals for years to get quite a limited amount of calories out of them.
Lars (35:25)
Yeah,
David (35:26)
If you look at it from a very economical point of view.
So over time plant-based has to be the cheaper one. And we see this now already that our industry is upscaling the prices for the ingredients but also for the end consumer on the shelf decrease So in most countries we are already on price parity with conventional meat and fish
Lars (35:52)
Yeah, that's a that's a good point. That's also a good place to be. So you reach price parity and you've solved the science, you know, you built the factory, but then we also have you know the hardest part perhaps, the consumer. So let's
David (36:07)
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Lars (36:08)
talk a little bit about the consumer. Because like you said, we tend to do what we've always done, we eat we eat the food that we've always been eating,
Getting new thoughts into our heads is really, really hard. So how how do you actually go about trying to change people's perception and people's habits when it comes to something as fundamental as as eating or food? How do you do that?
David (36:37)
Yeah. First of all, the consumer is the hardest one to crack, but it's also the nicest because
Lars (36:43)
Mm-hmm.
David (36:44)
in the end we're all different. So we can take many different approaches to and try different solutions to change the behavior. How we are trying to do it now is basically offer a better product for at least the same price.
better nutrition for at least the same price. I'm not saying that we are a hundred percent there, but we are on our path
This in the end will benefit both the consumer and us and our industry if we crack this How we do it now, it's a lot of development. We first do obviously our recipe developments, then we do a lot of internal tastings. And once we see, in the internal tastings, we are happy and we feel like, this is a product that we could bring on the market. We do external tastings with people from out there.
who sometimes have expected opinions, sometimes also very unexpected opinions. again, you will also not make everyone happy. This is very normal. You get a wide range of opinions. then we need to decide, okay, do we reach enough consumers from the quality perspective that we can actually bring this product to the market?
as a startup, one big benefit is that you're just smaller and you're closer to consumer. Like I actually told you this before the podcast that I was at a vegan street food festival on Sunday where we did sampling with our products. And then you get like this direct feedback all day from consumers. yeah, it's just super nice to hear because in the end, this also motivates you a
products are liked and you get good feedback for them.
Lars (38:28)
Yeah,
yeah. I think that's super important, get direct, honest feedback from the consumers and then you change rapidly.
David (38:35)
Yeah, thank you.
Lars (38:37)
I'm I'm guessing that your products are still perhaps strongest among vegan and vegetarian consumers, but probably the real growth opportunity is let let's call them the flexitarian majority, you
David (38:50)
Hmm
Lars (38:51)
Like myself. know, I I
David (38:52)
You
Lars (38:52)
I would like to do, eat, you know, healthy, sustainable, ethical,
David (38:58)
Mm-hmm.
Lars (38:58)
but it's still it still it still needs to, you know, taste good and I still need to understand what I'm what I'm eating.
David (39:06)
Mm-hmm.
Lars (39:08)
w what will make an ordinary meat or fish eater choose Revo
David (39:15)
Yeah, at the beginning it was obviously the goal to offer something to vegans and vegetarians liked, they're probably like 2 % vegans in the population on average 10 % are vegetarians. And then depending on the countries where somewhere around 25 to 40 % of lexitarians. And this is like you're saying the market we want to these are the ones that actually also have the biggest impact.
have this transition from mainly animal based nutrition to plant based protein products. It will have a huge impact. 40 % of the population is a lot. how we are trying to do is, like I said before, offer really good solutions on nutrition, quality.
and also price and also convenience. So they need to be able to use the product the same way as the conventional shouldn't need to think about, how do I even prepare this meal now? If they buy a salmon fillet, can bake it like a salmon fillet, can put it in the oven. They can bake it in a pan, they can put it on the grill, they can combine it with potatoes like normally, they can put lemon over it.
So to actually deliver on all these aspects, we are convinced if we do this, then the consumer will also change the behavior and consume our products.
Lars (40:38)
Does it is it also a bit about marketing how how do you market this? Do you market this as being the sustainable option or is it the ethical option? is it the cheap option or is it all of the above? I guess marketing is is important as well.
David (40:57)
Yeah, of course, especially nowadays for smaller companies, have a lot of opportunities with social media and that's what we're trying to do a lot, obviously. And
Lars (41:06)
Mm.
David (41:07)
in our marketing messages, we always try to convey the positive messaging and the optimistic point of view. crisis, animal welfare, all this is surrounded by a lot of negativity and...
picture for
Lars (41:22)
Mm.
David (41:22)
good reasons. But this is not what we want to do in our marketing message because in the end you also want to enjoy your food and you want to have
positive feeling positive feeling is probably the right phrase here while eating it and you do not want to think, okay, I'm only eating this now because it's more sustainable. You want to eat it because it's it's a probably even better product than the conventional one. It's even healthier for me and I feel better afterwards.
sustainability point of view, but also from taste and nutritional point of view. So this is what we're trying to achieve in our marketing campaigns.
Lars (42:02)
Yeah. maybe you can compare it to, electric cars. the first electric cars were really shit, if we if you're honest, you know, they they were small, they're they're they were slow, they were uncomfortable, but still, I mean the idealist they still bought them, you but then then suddenly you had the Tesla, which was, this is this looks nice, it's fast, it's it's luxurious.
I'll buy the Tesla. And then of course you get, you know, hopefully at least the sustainability
David (42:31)
Mhm.
Lars (42:32)
effects, you know, as an add-on. But probably that wasn't why you why you bought the Teslas. I mean I I think very few people actually bought Teslas because they were so sustainable. but maybe this is the same
David (42:45)
Exactly.
Lars (42:45)
yeah, it needs to taste.
really nice it needs to be fantastic maybe it it can be creative but of course it can't be a lot more expensive and you have already a price it also makes you feel good and you can of course use this as some kind of social currency
on social media. only eating, like the the 3D printing print printed salmon filet, and it makes me feel good. So yeah,
David (43:13)
Exactly.
Lars (43:14)
so may maybe it's like the Tesla.
David (43:17)
Yeah.
Hopefully the obstacle to buy your first plan B is a bit than to buy your first electric car because probably
Lars (43:23)
Yeah.
David (43:26)
the impact on your account is a bit
Lars (43:29)
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
David (43:30)
However, apart from that, I think it's a very good comparison. you reach the early adopters, which in our case obviously were the weekends. then from this, you try to get to the
to the mass market, which in our case is the flexitarians and in the electric car market is basically everyone who has a car and is open to
Lars (43:55)
Yeah, yeah. And of course you also have this this growing concern about ultra processed foods. There's been a lot of a lot of focus on that lately. So how do you respond when someone says, Why would I eat a 3D printed processed product rather than a piece of fish?
David (44:14)
Yeah, we actually see this a lot nowadays, not just in our industry, but also in other industries, like also for electrical cars, it's the same as cultural war and identity war between the, let's say more progressive and then more conservative parts of society. With food as it is so individual
Yeah, it's very personal in a way. This can become even more heated in a way. looking at the ultra-ultra-processed foods discussion now, it's sometimes, yeah, absurd what is discussed Like, first of all, there's not even a real definition out there. We are trying actually, and we're working on this now with organizations and
scientists to bring a definition out there what ultra processed food actually is. yeah, what the scientific consensus is right now is if you can if you combine high or products with high salt content with high saturated fat like chips, popcorn, for example, they should fall in the ultra processed foods category. But a product like ours, we have
We are high in protein, we are high in fibers, we are low in saturated fats, high in unsaturated fats like the healthy Omega-3 fatty acids. Products like these cannot count as ultra processed because in the end what you put in your body are really good nutrients and are very healthy for
Therefore, decades already, yogurt is processed. Every fermentation process is a process yeah, the discussion got a bit absurd because it was also so heated and in a way also pushed by the meat and milk industry a lot because they see the threat from the plant-based
Lars (46:02)
Mm-hmm.
David (46:04)
And this is like this pushback from them.
But we need to try to prove that we are on the right track by delivering healthy products and also stick to the scientific consensus there.
Lars (46:21)
Yeah, yeah. So w what what about regulation? like regulators may may actually restrict words such such as you know salmon or chicken. Yet you know those are the words that the consumer understands. so does does regulation sometimes make it harder rather than easier for consumers to know what they're actually buying?
David (46:41)
Yeah, definitely. European Union actually changed the regulations recently so a lot of names for plant-based products are not allowed. For example, fish, beef, pork, you cannot name it like this And this
Lars (46:52)
Mm.
David (46:53)
is also something that we needed to adapt to, which means we needed to figure out ways to...
tell the consumer what it is by using the same name. We are trying some workarounds now. regulations really will come into place in 2029, so we still have some time to figure this out for us. of course, it makes it more difficult for us, and this was also the goal of these new regulations and rules, which were obviously also pushed by the meat and milk industry.
Lars (47:23)
Yeah, I I guess they're quite powerful. Yeah.
David (47:27)
that's also
like the lobbying that has been built by those industries over the past 80 years are massive and huge resources they have for this are also very significant compared to an industry that the alternative protein industry which just came up the past five to 10 years, we obviously cannot compete with this. yeah, like I said, need to deliver.
good products and convince the consumer in other terms.
Lars (47:55)
Yeah, yeah. you've chosen some gigantic adversaries. but sometimes sometimes
David (47:59)
Yeah.
Lars (48:01)
David beats Goliath. So you can be you can be David. Yeah, that's that's good.
David (48:04)
Exactly.
Lars (48:10)
But but also I mean your products are made from from mycoprotein, which is made from fungi. So it isn't really a plant, is it?
David (48:19)
Mmm.
Lars (48:19)
uh
d does that mean that the phrase plant based meat itself will disappear? maybe next generation proteins won't fit into our our old categories?
David (48:31)
Yeah, very true. the very first plant based products were mainly on pea protein, soy protein, gluten. And now this next generation, the second generation, where I also count as in, I'm using those new protein sources like mycoprotein, which is fungi based, like you correctly said, but now also precision fermentation is coming up. Then hopefully in the next decades also cell based.
solutions, cell-based meat, cell-based fish will come up. This will still take a while, especially on a price point of but there are many different ways to offer solutions. Our approach was, okay, we want to use ingredients that are already regulated and that we can immediately place on the market. So that's also why we chose to use microprotein. And also it's just a fantastic product.
It has a full amino acid profile compared to beef. has a bioavailability, which also goes against this argument from our adversaries that what we offer is not healthy for We can prove scientifically that it offers many benefits for consumers.
Yeah, that's how we approach it.
Lars (49:45)
Yeah, absolutely. So David, this podcast is called The World in Twenty Twenty Nine. I always finish off with with asking you know the the guests what what do you think will happen in in twenty twenty-nine in in your industry? So me into the supermarket in twenty twenty-nine.
How how does the protein section look like? What has changed compared with with today?
David (50:13)
If I look at the shelves or if I think about the shelves that have been on the market three years ago, actually, and if I look what has changed in this short period of time already, I'm very convinced that we will further transition to more plant-based and fungi-based products on the shelf and going away from animal-based sources. And yeah.
A lot depends also on the further regulatory framework that's going to happen. So that's why politicians and the rules we're deciding for how we live together play a very significant role here. However, we also see that there's a lot of transformation within supermarket and retail chains. So there are also a lot of people in there who are working towards changing what they're offering.
this is why I'm very convinced that we will make this next step to offer healthier and better and more plant-based products in the supermarkets.
Lars (51:12)
Yeah. and what needs to happen for you to succeed? beyond the the vegans and the vegetarians and you're reaching that big market of flexitarians, what what needs to happen before somebody like me, you know, normally buys saddle or chicken, starts buying your products regularly, you know, even without thinking of them as alternative. What needs to happen?
David (51:39)
I think we just need to further improve our products. How much we have improved as an industry in the past five years and also as Revo Foods in the past five years. This makes me very convinced that at some point and possibly in 2029 already, we cannot just offer equally good products, but even better products than what is out there. And this is our end goal.
as an organization and should also be as an industry that we not just
that we do not just offer something equally good, to improve even what is out there on sustainability, taste, price and quality perspective.
Lars (52:20)
Yeah. And if if you want to quantify this, I mean how much of humanities protein problem could actually technologies like this realistically solve by twenty twenty nine?
David (52:36)
That's very difficult
Lars (52:38)
huh.
David (52:38)
to quantify, but the technologies
Lars (52:40)
Yeah.
David (52:41)
could solve the problem. However, in the end, the consumers also need to accept it. And it's a bit of a back and forth issue we try to improve, but then the consumers also need to be open to try it again and give us a new chance because
with this first generation of products where we were just not good enough, where we thought, okay, just the sustainability aspect is enough for the consumer to change. We probably also made a lot of consumers never try it again because they thought, I don't like this. What they're offering me is not good enough. And they never went back to try it again. this was definitely a big mistake back then,
also is part of the process of a new industry. If I take the analogy of the electrical cars, the first ones were also not that good. They didn't have the reach they're having now. looking at now, they're probably even better already than the normal cars with gas and gasoline. So this is also where our industry is heading.
Lars (53:44)
Yeah, I think so as well. And of course, this doesn't move in a linear fashion, it moves in an exponential fashion. So that means
David (53:51)
Exactly.
Lars (53:52)
that even though it's just just over three years until the end of 2029, you know it it will still be quite different from today. yeah,
David (54:01)
Hopefully,
Lars (54:03)
yeah, fingers crossed. I think it's definitely
David (54:05)
Hahaha
Lars (54:06)
going that way. do you do you also believe that this could be
part of let's say solving solving hunger because today according to the UN six hundred and fifty million people among them 150 million children are going to bed hungry every day this is we we we need to change that we need to solve that and do you think that this could be part of that solution?
David (54:33)
If we look at it now, we already do have the resources that everyone would have enough to eat. We're just not distributing it wisely However, if we look at it we do work and to provide more, a more efficient food system where we leave out the animal cruelty and
directly go to the source, plants. We will also have more supply available a lot of this supply then could also be distributed globally we do not have hunger in the southern spheres of our globe.
Lars (55:09)
Yeah. that's my hope as well. I definitely think we are going this this And I think that what you're doing is you know, I think it's amazing think it's it's going to just grow and improve uh
David (55:22)
Hmm.
Lars (55:23)
definitely be part of you know that transition and know yes we do already produce enough food for everyone but it's not equally distributed as
David (55:35)
Exactly.
Lars (55:36)
I think this could be both a sustainable, ethical, and and really good source of protein for you know a lot of people. that this has been a fantastic talk, David. You know, I I really like this. it's you're doing fantastic work. And yeah, it seems to me that we are actually you know going into an era where we can actually eat you know really nice food.
which is healthy, which is sustainable, which is ethical. know, I also like that you call it, you know, manufactured. You know, I think that's fantastic. It opens so many, so many possibilities. thank you so much for joining me and thank you for sharing your your inspiring journey and your your company. And to everyone listening, you know, subscribe
Share the episode, help David and Revo Foods, follow the podcast for more conversations with the entrepreneurs and researchers who are building the world we'll live in next. And remember, the future is better than you think. Thank you.
David (56:43)
Thank you Lars.
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Lex Fridman Podcast
Lex Fridman
Moonshots with Peter Diamandis
PHD Ventures